USB dock · Disk Management · a friend's recorder · same make, different model · 'initialise?' · what was clicked · leave it alone now · £400 + VAT
The drive was put in a PC or another recorder. Every device a recorder's drive is shown to will fail to read it and offer to wipe it. The harm depends on the answer given.
It is the obvious experiment, and nearly everyone who removes a recorder's drive tries it. Connected to a computer, the drive appears empty or unformatted, because the computer does not know the recorder's file system. Fitted in another recorder, even one from the same maker, it is reported as uninitialised or foreign, because recorders are particular about disks they did not prepare themselves. In both cases the device then offers to fix the problem by initialising or formatting. If the offer was refused, nothing has been lost and the drive is as it was. If it was accepted, something has been written, and what matters is how much.
Switch the recorder off first. Then tell us the make, what happened and the date you need: we say what is realistic before you pay anything
0800 6890668
What can and cannot come back.
What was done, and what it wrote to the drive.
| What was done | What it wrote to the drive | What usually survives | What the bench does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Connected to a PC, prompt cancelled | Nothing | Everything | Read normally |
| Initialised in Windows | A partition table at the start | The video | Blocks read directly |
| Quick-formatted in Windows | A new file system's tables | Most of the video | As above; longer |
| Fitted in another recorder, prompt declined | Nothing | Everything | Read normally |
| Initialised in another recorder | A new index; new recording if cameras were attached | The video, less anything recorded since | As for a format |
| PC recovery software run | Nothing, unless it saved to the same drive | Everything, usually | Read normally |
What to do now, in order.
- Disconnect itFrom the PC, the dock or the other recorder.
- Write down each thing that was triedDevice, what the screen said, what was clicked, and for how long it ran.
- Do not try a third deviceEach one asks the same question.
- Keep the original recorder's detailsMake and model, from the label underneath. It tells the bench which format to expect.
- Send the drive and the notesThe notes save time and decide where the examination starts.
Do not
- Do not accept any prompt to initialise, format, repair or scan.
- Do not buy an identical recorder to read the drive.
- Do not leave the drive in a working recorder 'to see if it picks it up'.
- Do not save recovered files from PC software back to the same drive.
- Do not be embarrassed to say what was tried. It is the commonest history there is.
In more detail.
Why a computer cannot read it
The best-documented recorder format begins with a master sector carrying the maker's signature, followed by logs, large fixed-size blocks of video and an index. It has no partition table and no file system a PC knows. A forum post from the main open-source forensic toolkit makes the same point about the other major make: the standard tool 'doesn't understand' its file system. If specialist forensic software needs dedicated support for these formats, Windows Explorer has no chance. The drive is not empty. It is written in a language the computer does not speak.
Why another recorder is no better
It seems reasonable that a recorder from the same maker would read its sibling's drive. In practice recorders tie a drive to the unit that initialised it, by model, firmware generation or an identifier written to the disk, and a drive from elsewhere is shown as uninitialised. One maker's own instructions for a newly fitted drive say the unit 'should ask to initialize the drive, select yes/ok'. A second recorder is therefore a second chance to press the wrong button, with the added hazard that if cameras are connected it will begin recording on the old drive at once.
How it is read instead
The drive is imaged: every sector copied to a file, with nothing interpreted. The image is then examined with tools that understand recorder formats, or, for formats no tool supports, by locating the video frames by their markers and rebuilding the sequence from the time and channel information held with them. Published research describes both approaches. Nothing in that process needs the recorder, a recorder of the same model, or its password, and none of it writes to the original drive, which is returned as it arrived.
- Han, Jeong and Lee, 'Analysis of the HIKVISION DVR File System', ICDF2C 2015 (Springer LNICST) — eudl.eu/pdf/10.1007/978-3-319-25512-5_13
- Sleuth Kit forum, 'Support for DHFS file system' (forum thread) — sleuthkit.discourse.group/t/support-for-dhfs-file-system-or-unknown-file-system/2006
- Hikvision USA support, 'What do I do after I install a new hard drive?' — supportusa.hikvision.com/support/solutions/articles/17000129501-what-do-i-do-after-i-install-a-new-hard-drive-
- Rzayeva et al., 'Automated Forensic Recovery Methodology for Video Evidence from Hikvision and Dahua DVR/NVR Systems', Information 2025, 16(11):983 — www.mdpi.com/2078-2489/16/11/983
- Magnet Forensics, DVR Examiner release notes on file-system support (vendor) — www.magnetforensics.com/blog/stream_db_i_e4-filesystem-support-now-available-in-dvr-examiner-3-1-5/
Quotations were checked against the sources listed in November 2026. Makers change their support pages and manuals; follow the links for the current wording. Research figures are the authors' results on their own drives. No maker, regulator or police body listed is connected with this site.
Asked after this happens.
Why does my PC say the CCTV drive is empty?
Because it cannot read the recorder's file system. The drive is not empty.
Will the drive work in another recorder of the same make?
Usually not. The second recorder will treat it as new and offer to initialise it.
What does it cost?
£400 + VAT for one drive, paid upfront and non-refundable.
Switched off. Drive out. Then tell us what happened.
Tell us the recorder, what happened and the date you need. The reply, inside a working day, says whether the footage is likely to be on the drive. Nothing is charged for that. Recovery is £400 + VAT per working drive, paid upfront and non-refundable; failing or damaged drives cost more and are quoted first.