Click, click, click · spins up and stops · faint beeping · silent and cold · 24 hours a day for years · every power-up counts · takes longer, costs more
A clicking or silent hard drive. A recorder's drive works harder than any other in the building. When it starts to click, stop asking it to try.
A hard drive in a recorder writes video every second of every day, usually in a closed metal box on a shelf with no airflow. Surveillance-rated drives are built for that and still wear out; ordinary desktop drives put to the same work wear out sooner. The end is announced by sound. A regular click is the drive's heads failing to find their place and returning to try again. A spin-up followed by a sigh and silence is the drive giving up. A faint electronic beep is a motor that cannot turn. Silence is dead electronics. In each case the drive has a limited number of working hours left, perhaps very few, and they should be spent on being imaged.
Switch the recorder off first. Then tell us the make, what happened and the date you need: we say what is realistic before you pay anything
0800 6890668
(the drive itself)
What can and cannot come back.
Why it says that.
The third column is the question that matters most: if the recorder stopped recording when the message began, nothing after that point exists.
| Likely cause | How to tell | Was it still recording? | What the bench does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regular clicking | Heads cannot read the positioning tracks | No | Imaged with head-by-head control; may need parts |
| Spins up, then stops | Fails its own start-up checks | No | Start-up controlled by the imaging hardware |
| Faint beep or buzz | Motor stalled, heads stuck to the platter | No | Mechanical work before any reading |
| Silent, no vibration | Electronics dead, often after a surge | No | Board-level work, then usually a full image |
| Scraping or grinding | Heads in contact with the platter surface | No | Often little is recoverable. Do not power it again |
| Works, with errors | Bad sectors spreading | Patchily | Imaged at once, before it worsens |
What to do, in order.
- Switch off and leave it offThe most useful thing you can do costs nothing.
- Note the sound and when it beganClicking, spin-down, beep, silence. And whether there was a power event.
- Remove the drive gentlyNo knocks. Hold it by its edges. Leave the circuit board on it.
- Pack it for the postAnti-static bag, then at least five centimetres of padding all round in a rigid box.
- Say what has been triedOther recorders, a PC, the freezer. It affects how the first power-up is handled.
Do not
- Do not keep switching it on to see if it recovers.
- Do not tap it, shake it or put it in the freezer.
- Do not open the drive's sealed casing.
- Do not swap its circuit board with another drive's.
- Do not run software on it for hours 'scanning' for bad sectors.
The message, in more detail.
Why recorder drives fail
Drive makers publish what their surveillance ranges are built for. Western Digital describes its Purple drives as having 'a workload rating of up to 180TB/year - up to three times that of desktop drives', and Seagate describes SkyHawk as 'designed for always-on workloads of 180 TB/year'. Those figures say two things. Recording is heavy work, and a desktop drive is rated for about a third of it. Recorders are also often fitted in lofts, cupboards and above ceilings, where heat shortens a drive's life further, and they are exposed to every power cut and surge the building suffers.
What imaging a failing drive involves
An ordinary computer reads a drive by asking for data and waiting. A failing drive answers slowly or not at all, and the computer's retries hammer the same weak spot. Imaging hardware built for the purpose takes control: it can read with the heads that still work, pass over damaged regions quickly and return to them later, limit how long the drive spends on any one sector, and power-cycle it when it hangs. Published work on recorder recovery specifically addresses extracting video from a 'hard disk with part of damaged sector'. A recorder's video suits this, since a gap of a few sectors costs a few frames, not a whole file.
Being realistic
Three outcomes are possible. Most often, the image is complete or nearly so and the footage is recovered as from a healthy drive, with short breaks where sectors were lost. Sometimes the image is partial: the drive failed for good part-way, and what you receive is the video from the part that was read, which may or may not include your date. Occasionally nothing can be read, usually because the platter surfaces have been damaged by continued running. A failing drive also takes longer than the usual turnaround and costs more than the standard fee, which is for a working drive. The extra is quoted before the work is done. The work is carried out in all three cases, and what is paid is not refunded in any of them.
- Western Digital, WD Purple surveillance hard drives — www.westerndigital.com/en-sg/products/internal-drives/wd-purple-sata-hdd
- Seagate, SkyHawk surveillance hard drives — www.seagate.com/products/video-analytics/skyhawk-hard-drive/
- Yang, Li and Wu, 'Basic Principle and Application of Video Recovery Software for Dahua and Hikvision Brand', SHS Web of Conferences 14 (2015) — doaj.org/article/70994b3b90834c3689cabf8815611700
- SWGDE Best Practices for Computer Forensic Acquisitions v2.0 (image types, hashing, records to keep) — www.swgde.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/2023-06-15-SWGDE-Best-Practices-for-Computer-Forensic-Acquisitions-17-F-002-2.0.pdf
- Hikvision USA support, tips on hard disk settings on Hikvision recorders — supportusa.hikvision.com/support/solutions/articles/17000130208-do-you-have-any-tips-regarding-hard-disk-settings-on-hikvision-recorders-
Quotations were checked against the sources listed in November 2026. Makers change their support pages and manuals; follow the links for the current wording. Research figures are the authors' results on their own drives. No maker, regulator or police body listed is connected with this site.
Asked about this message.
The drive is clicking. Can footage still be recovered?
Often, in whole or part. It depends on what is failing and how long it was left running.
Should I try it once more?
No. Each power-up of a failing drive risks the part that still works.
What does a failing drive cost?
More than the standard £400 + VAT, which is for a working drive. The extra is quoted before the work is done. Fees are paid upfront and are non-refundable.
Switched off. Drive out. Then tell us what happened.
Tell us the recorder, what happened and the date you need. The reply, inside a working day, says whether the footage is likely to be on the drive. Nothing is charged for that. Recovery is £400 + VAT per working drive, paid upfront and non-refundable; failing or damaged drives cost more and are quoted first.